Perspective - Manx Radio

On Perspective last week economist John Webster identified significant areas for improvement in the Island’s economic policies. He marked the Treasury Minister’s card with - could do better - see me after the lesson. Members of the Chamber of Commerce were particularly concerned in their assessment of February’s budget and its impact on their businesses. The recently released Tax Strategy has been criticised in many quarters for being very light in substance. Treasury Minister Alex Allinson joins Phil Gawne to respond to some of the criticism. Should we be grateful for being asked to pay more tax for improved services?

John Webster is an economist, business owner and Chairman of the Manx Technology Group as well as an independent adviser to various investment funds and involved with the UN as an economic adviser to small islands. He was also economic adviser to the Isle of Man Government back in the 1980s so he’s well qualified to talk about the economic situation in the Isle of Man. On Perspective John Webster joins me Phil Gawne to talk about the Budget, the newly released tax strategy and what steps should be taken to ensure the Isle of Man prospers again in the future.

A new exhibition exploring the Isle of Man’s remarkable maritime heritage and honouring the 200th anniversary of the RNLI opened recently at the House of Manannan in Peel.  ‘All at Sea’ uncovers some of the tragic events in Manx waters which motivated Manx resident, Sir William Hillary to establish a national maritime lifesaving institution. On Perspective this week we talk to the people behind the exhibition and consider the vital role that Hillary played in saving lives at sea. The story of the RNLI is undoubtedly a source of great pride for the Manx people.

The Budget has been met with mixed reviews since it was announced on Tuesday. Perspective unpicks some of the thinking behind it, with help from the Treasury Minister and some of his Tynwald colleagues. We are promised improved services and certainly the significant budgetary increases in health and education would indicate that, but we’re also paying a lot more tax this year and government continues to deplete our hard earned reserves. Will Alex Allinson’s high spending and high tax budget reap economic and service delivery rewards or is government spending now out of control?

If you’ve visited the hospital lately you may well have seen Braddan Parish Commissioners’ magnificent new community hub has emerged in all its glory. Close followers of Manx politics may also have noticed the rather large 37% increase in Braddan’s rates part of which will be used to cover the costs of the new hub. As if this wasn’t enough to encourage me to cover the story on Perspective, there’s also the spat between Braddan and the Health Department over site access. Is this a white elephant or bold ambition for the people of Braddan? Naive mismanagement from the Commissioners or stubborn intransigence from the Health Minister?

Just over 23 years ago Tynwald agreed that government should defend vigorously the Island's internal governing autonomy and seek to extend the Isle of Man's influence over relevant external issues. While there were some modest gains made in the early 2000s, little or no work has been done to reform our constitutional relationship with the UK over the past few decades. Is that about to change? On Perspective this Sunday at 12 noon on Manx Radio we hear the evidence given by long serving Jersey politician Sir Philip Bailhache KC to Tynwald’s Constitutional and Legal Affairs and Justice Committee. Would independence work for the Isle of Man?  

New schools, underfunded departmental budgets better roads and a new bus station are on the wish lists of MHKs Joney Faragher and Michelle Haywood. The government is struggling to control a substantial financial deficit so where is the money coming from? Hopefully we’ll know more when this year’s Manx budget is delivered in just over a week’s time but the MHKs give their take on Perspective. Treasury’s magic money tree has been diseased for sometime now so can we continue to shake it without addressing the financial diseases that afflict it?

The southern swimming pool has been making a splash in the turbulent Tynwald political waters leaving some political commentators to suggest that the Minister is out of her depth. In contrast the Minister has suggested that some members are floundering in the political whirlpool and the whole pool debate has allowed a range of thorny administrative issues to float to the surface. Diving in with both feet to try to make sense of it all.

The economic strategy annual update was debated in Tynwald this week with the Chief Minister painting a very rosy Manx economic picture which seemed to avoid discussion of the pitfalls and obstacles to economic success. This led to criticism from some members that perhaps government wasn’t living in the real world or indeed that the Chief Minister was living on ‘fantasy island.’ So who’s right? You get the opportunity to decide by listening to this week's Perspective. The Chief Minister certainly has a dream but is his government delivering?

Perspective looks at the forthcoming January Tynwald, Systra's report into Heritage railways and guests MHKs Daphne Caine, Sarah Maltby and Chris Thomas give their initial reaction to the Covid Review.

Tynwald gave Government two modest defeats this week as well as pointing out that Government is missing a number of its own targets. Statistics show that the population is growing by 230 people a year but the Chief Minister is convinced that his government’s flagship target of an extra ten thousand people. The Treasury Minister announced that he will be announcing his tax strategy in February but most taxes will stay the same. Tynwald may have been in training for a couple of years but it certainly appears to be throwing some well placed punches at government this month.

The Financial Services Authority is a body whose influence we only tend to come across when we’re trying to open a bank account and having to prove in triplicate who we are. The FSA has, though, a significant influence on the financial services sector which generates over a third of our economic output so we probably do need to know a bit more about them. The FSA talks in its recent report of a need for change so what’s driving that change and how will this FSA shape the future of the Manx finance industry? Money makes the world go round but only if it can prove who it is and where it lives!

Crogga wants to give the Isle of Man Government a multibillion pound Christmas present but needs government to agree a variation to their gas exploration licence. The Chief Minister apparently sacked Chris Thomas for not assisting Crogga so the decision is now in Tim Crookall’s hands. Several Tynwald members and a growing international chorus suggest that extracting more fossil fuels during the climate emergency is no longer acceptable. So who’s right? Should we go for the gas? Crogga appears to be drinking in the last chance saloon but with the Infrastructure Minister provide them with festive cheer?

You wait around for twenty years for some renewable energy projects and then suddenly several of them arrive at the same time. Tynwald seems very nervous about accepting private sector support for renewable power generation in the Isle of Man, but perhaps they might be persuaded by a project which gives a significant boost to Manx farmers, ticks all the boxes for carbon reduction targets and provides low cost district heating. Certainly those behind the Proposed Renewable Energy Generation Hub at Andreas Airfield hope so. Find out more about what is proposed and how the project would work on this week's Perspective. Is biogas the answer or is it just a load of hot air?

Has the Manx milling wheat sector reached a crisis point? Is government borrowing over a billion pounds now? No say the relevant Ministers. The Treasury Minister is feeling generous by handing out winter and Christmas bonuses and free TV licences for over 75s. Tynwald likes onshore wind farms and agrees that the airport and the sea terminal need tidying up. The DoI Minister announces some tinkering with his Department’s responsibilities. Tynwald is far from happy with Isle of Man Energy. Find out all about the November sitting of Tynwald on this episode of Perspective. All the political skeet you ever wished for … possibly even more!  

How has the mild mannered generally innocuous Health Services Consultative Committee been drawn in to a heated political debate with the Health Minister? Lawrie Hooper has accused the committee of deliberated falsehood - lying to you and me - and both sides have accused each other of making defamatory statements. Chris Thomas will be calling on Tynwald to annul changes made to the Committee’s constitution at this month’s sitting, so what on earth is going on. We try to find out on Perspective this week. Is independent scrutiny being silenced or is this just an important change of focus?

A bit of déjà vu  on Agenda this week as the Bishop’s vote is once more called into question this time by the House of Keys who narrowly voted to allow Lawrie Hooper to introduce a private member’s Bill to remove the vote from the Bishop. Mr Hooper was accused of having malevolent purpose and being distracted by trivial matters when he should be getting on with the day job of fixing health services. We consider the latest debate on Agenda. Is the vote of the non elected Bishop any different to the votes of the other eight democratically unaccountable LegCo members? Or is this a necessary change to bring our parliament into the 21st Century?

A trio of appointments were announced this week by government with MHKs John Wannenburgh and Tim Glover taking over as chairs of Manx Utilities and Office of Fair Trading, subject to Tynwald approval. John is current Chair at the OFT and Rob Callister was Chair at the MUA last year. Rob now takes over as Chair of planning? Did you follow that? Well light and clarity will be delivered on Perspective. Does OFT have enough power and resource to protect consumers? Is planning fit for purpose and will governments planning reform agenda deliver? Will your electricity bills be safe in John Wannenburgh’s hands?

Few people can have managed to avoid being affected by the tragic events taking place in Israel and Gaza in recent weeks. The suffering and pain being inflicted is hard to imagine in our peaceful island which hasn’t witnessed war and bloodshed for many decades. We have little power to influence these events but should we not at least consider what’s happening and use our comparitively small political voice to bring about change? One MHK certainly thinks we should and she tells us why on Perspective . Does our close neighbour Northern Ireland offer hope for a peaceful solution? 

Relationship breakdowns can be very difficult and never more so when played out publicly on the floor of Tynwald and Keys. Once popular and valued CoMin team member Chris Thomas had his political heart broken by the Chief Minister and it could be argued that he’s out for revenge. We listen again to the extraordinary and revelatory session in Keys this week as the former DoI Minister Chris Thomas asked searching questions about Crogga. Has government been too keen to help Crogga or is this just sour grapes from a heart broken former Minister?